2019 season
Champions: Princeton
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Princeton | 13-1 | 18-13 | — |
| T-2. George Mason | 10-4 | 17-9 | -3 |
| T-2. Penn State | 10-4 | 15-15 | -3 |
| 4. St. Francis | 9-5 | 15-14 | -4 |
| T-5. Harvard | 5-9 | 6-16 | -8 |
| T-5. NJIT | 5-9 | 10-14 | -8 |
| 7. Sacred Heart | 3-11 | 5-16 | -10 |
| 8. Charleston | 1-13 | 9-20 | -12 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Player of the Year
George Huhmann, Princeton
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Henrik Falck Lauten, Penn State
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Sam Shweisky, Princeton
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Matt Ctvrtlik, Harvard
Opposite: George Huhmann, Princeton
Opposite: Hayden Wagner, George Mason
Outside attacker: Parker Dixon, Princeton
Outside attacker: Michael Fisher, Saint Francis
Outside attacker: Alvaro Gimeno, NJIT
Outside attacker: Sam Greenslade, George Mason
Middle attacker: Luca Berger, NJIT
Middle attacker: Jason Donorovich, Penn State
Libero: Will Calaman, George Mason
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: BJ Blair, Saint Francis
Setter: Joe Kelly, Princeton
Outside attacker: Kyle Barnes, George Mason
Outside attacker: Henrik Falck Lauten, Penn State
Outside attacker: Greg Luck, Princeton
Outside attacker: Matthew McLaren, Penn State
Outside attacker: Kendall Ratter, Princeton
Middle attacker: Enrique de Diego Garcia, NJIT
Middle attacker: Jack Reese, George Mason
Libero: Will Bantle, Penn State
All-EIVA Honorable Mentions
Setter: Luis Velez, George Mason
Setter: Roque Nido, NJIT
Opposite: Emerson Waumans, Sacred Heart
Opposite: Brett Wildman, Penn State
Outside attacker: Campbell Schoenfeld, Harvard
Middle attacker: Trevor Dow, Harvard
Middle attacker: Adriel Roberts, Charleston
EIVA All-Tournament Team
Setter: Joe Kelly, Princeton
Opposite/middle: George Huhmann, Princeton
Opposite: Hayden Wagner, George Mason
Outside attacker: Brett Wildman, Penn State
Outside attacker: Henrik Falck Lauten, Penn State
Outside attacker: Parker Dixon, Princeton
2018 season
Champions: Harvard
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. George Mason | 13-1 | 17-12 | — |
| T-2. Penn State | 10-4 | 15-11 | -3 |
| T-2. Harvard | 10-4 | 13-14 | -3 |
| 4. Princeton | 7-7 | 12-16 | -6 |
| T-5. Charleston | 5-9 | 16-10 | -8 |
| T-5. NJIT | 5-9 | 9-17 | -8 |
| 7. St. Francis | 4-10 | 9-20 | -9 |
| 8. Sacred Heart | 2-12 | 7-15 | -11 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Player of the Year
Brian Negron, George Mason
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Alvaro Gimeno, NJIT
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Jay Hosack, George Mason
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Marko Kostich, Harvard
Setter: Brian Negron, George Mason
Opposite: Alvaro Gimeno, NJIT
Opposite: George Huhmann, Princeton
Opposite: Calvin Mende, Penn State
Opposite: Hayden Wagner, George Mason
Outside attacker: Kyle Barnes, George Mason
Outside attacker: Brad Gretsch, Harvard
Outside attacker: Matthew McLaren, Penn State
Libero: Joshua Ayzenberg, Sacred Heart
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Matthew Ctvrtlik, Harvard
Opposite: Piotr Namiotko, NJIT
Outside attacker: Stephen Braswell, St. Francis
Outside attacker: Christian Malias, George Mason
Outside attacker: Max Senica, Charleston
Middle attacker: Kevin Gear, Penn State
Middle attacker: Riley Moore, Harvard
Middle attacker: Junior Oboh, Princeton
Middle attacker: Jack Reese, George Mason
Libero: Johnny Gomez, George Mason
2017 season
Champions: Penn State
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 11-3 | 21-11 | — |
| 2. St. Francis | 10-4 | 16-15 | -1 |
| 3. Sacred Heart | 8-6 | 15-11 | -3 |
| 4. Princeton | 8-6 | 12-14 | -3 |
| 5. Harvard | 7-7 | 10-13 | -4 |
| T-6. George Mason | 6-8 | 13-14 | -5 |
| T-6. NJIT | 6-8 | 13-13 | -5 |
| 8. Charleston | 0-14 | 12-17 | -11 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Player of the Year
Jabarry Goodridge, NJIT
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
George Huhmann, Princeton
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Greg Walker, Sacred Heart
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Daniel Ford, St. Francis
Oppoiste: Jeff Hogan, St. Francis
Opposite: Calvin Mende, Penn State
Opposite: Jack Wilson, George Mason
Outside attacker: Christopher DeLucie, Sacred Heart
Outside attacker: Jabarry Goodridge, NJIT
Outside attacker: Chris Nugent, Penn State
Middle attacker: George Huhmann, Princeton
Middle attacker: Junior Oboh, Princeton
Libero: Josh Ayzenberg, Sacred Heart
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Marko Kostich, Harvard
Setter: Eduardo Zardo, Sacred Heart
Opposite: Parker Dixon, Princeton
Outside attacker: Aidan Albrecht, Penn State
Outside attacker: Stephen Braswell, St. Francis
Outside attacker: Michael Fisher, St. Francis
Outside attacker: Casey White, Harvard
Middle attacker: Luke Robbe, NJIT
Libero: Johnny Gomez, George Mason
Libero: Gabe Woffindin, St. Francis
2016 season
Champions: George Mason
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 12-2 | 19-10 | — |
| 2. George Mason | 10-4 | 18-12 | -2 |
| 3. Harvard | 9-5 | 13-11 | -3 |
| 4. St. Francis | 9-5 | 19-10 | -3 |
| 5. NJIT | 7-7 | 8-18 | -5 |
| 6. Sacred Heart | 5-9 | 7-17 | -7 |
| 7. Princeton | 4-10 | 4-18 | -8 |
| 8. Charleston | 0-14 | 4-24 | -12 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Co-Player of the Year
Jabarry Goodridge, NJIT
Chris Nugent, Penn State
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Royce Clemens, Penn State
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Jay Hosack, George Mason
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Taylor Hammond, Penn State
Opposite: Branden Clemens, Harvard
Outside attacker: Austin Arcala, Sacred Heart
Outside attacker: Stephen Braswell, St. Francis
Outside attacker: Jabarry Goodridge, NJIT
Outside attacker: Chris Nugent, Penn State
Middle attacker: Dom Edgley, George Mason
Middle attacker: Mike Marshman, St. Francis
Middle attacker: Matt Seifert, Penn State
Libero: Johnny Gomez, George Mason
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Daniel Ford, St. Francis
Setter: Marko Kostich, Harvard
Opposite: Christopher DeLucie, Sacred Heart
Opposite: Jeff Hogan, St. Francis
Outside attacker: TJ Jurko, NJIT
Outside attacker: Christian Malias, George Mason
Outside attacker: Radoslav Popov, George Mason
Outside attacker: Devin Stearns, Princeton
Outside attacker: Casey White, Harvard
Libero: Joshua Ayzenberg, Sacred Heart
2015 season
Champions: Penn State
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 12-0 | 21-10 | — |
| T-2. George Mason | 7-5 | 15-13 | -5 |
| T-2. Harvard | 7-5 | 13-12 | -5 |
| 3. Princeton | 6-6 | 11-13 | -5 |
| 5. Saint Francis | 4-8 | 6-20 | -8 |
| T-6. Sacred Heart | 3-9 | 12-13 | -9 |
| T-6. NJIT | 3-9 | 11-13 | -10 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Player of the Year
Aaron Russell, Penn State
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Brian Negron, George Mason
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Mark Pavlik, Penn State
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Brian Negron, George Mason
Opposite: Branden Clemens, Harvard
Opposite: Cody Kessel, Princeton
Outside attacker: Enzo Mackenzie, Sacred Heart
Outside attacker: Aaron Russell, Penn State
Outside attacker: DJ White, Harvard
Middle attacker: Mike Marshman St. Francis
Middle attacker: Junior Oboh, Princeton
Middle attacker: Caleb Zimmick, Harvard
Libero: Connor Curry, Penn State
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Taylor Hammond, Penn State
Setter: Chris Kennedy, Princeton
Opposite: Nick Goodell, Penn State
Outside attacker: Jabarry Goodridge, NJIT
Outside attacker: Radoslav Popov, George Mason
Middle attacker: Will Siroky, Princeton
Middle attacker: Hunter Stevens, George Mason
Middle attacker: Ryan Thomas, NJIT
Middle attacker: Travis Vonholt, Sacred Heart
Libero: Oren Zyndorf, NJIT
2014 season
Champions: Penn State
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 13-1 | 25-7 | — |
| 2. Harvard | 11-3 | 15-8 | -2 |
| 3. Princeton | 10-4 | 16-10 | -3 |
| 4. George Mason | 8-6 | 14-14 | -5 |
| 5. Saint Francis | 6-8 | 11-15 | -7 |
| 6. Sacred Heart | 4-10 | 10–18 | -9 |
| 7. NJIT | 3-11 | 10-17 | -10 |
| 8. Rutgers-Newark | 1-13 | 9-17 | -12 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Player of the Year
Aaron Russell, Penn State
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Radoslav Popov, George Mason
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Fred Chao, George Mason
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Taylor Hammond, Penn State
Opposite: Nick Goodell, Penn State
Opposite: Cody Kessel, Princeton
Opposite: Nick Madden, Harvard
Outside attacker: Radoslav Popov, George Mason
Outside attacker: Aaron Russell, Penn State
Outside attacker: DJ White, Harvard
Middle attacker: Mark Kochan, St. Francis
Middle attacker: Caleb Zimmick, Harvard
Libero: Tony Ensbury, Princeton
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Nick Bendell, Harvard
Opposite: Mike Marshman, St. Francis
Outside attacker: Brad Borsay, Sacred Heart
Outside attacker: Peter Russell, Penn State
Outside attacker: Pat Schwagler, Princeton
Outside attacker: Devin Stearns, Princeton
Middle attacker: Kyle Rehkemper, Harvard
Middle attacker: Matt Seifert, Penn State
Middle attacker: Hunter Stevens, George Mason
Libero: Connor Curry, Penn State
2013 season
Champions: Penn State
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 13-1 | 23-8 | — |
| 2. George Mason | 11-3 | 15-12 | -2 |
| 3. Harvard | 10-4 | 18-9 | -3 |
| 4. Princeton | 9-5 | 13-10 | -4 |
| 5. Saint Francis | 7-7 | 12-15 | -6 |
| 6. NJIT | 4-10 | 7-21 | -9 |
| 7. Sacred Heart | 2-12 | 4-19 | -11 |
| 8. Rutgers-Newark | 0-14 | 4-21 | -14 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Co-Players of the Year
Mark Jones, George Mason
Aaron Russell, Penn State
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Taylor Hammond, Penn State
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Mark Pavlik, Penn State
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Javier Perez, George Mason
Opposite: Mark Jones, George Mason
Opposite: Cody Kessel, Princeton
Outside attacker: Michael Kvidahl, George Mason
Outside attacker: Logan Patterson, St. Francis
Outside attacker: Aaron Russell, Penn State
Outside attacker: Pat Schwagler, Princeton
Outside attacker: DJ White, Harvard
Middle attacker: Pat Sibley, George Mason
Libero: Max McFarland, George Mason
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Taylor Hammond, Penn State
Setter: Rob Lothman, Harvard
Outside attacker: Andrew Dentler, George Mason
Outside attacker: Peter Russell, Penn State
Middle attacker: Michael Dye, Princeton
Middle attacker: Kyle Rehkemper, Harvard
Middle attacker: Matt Seifert, Penn State
Middle attacker: Caleb Zimmick, Harvard
Libero: Brady Smith, NJIT
2012 season
Champions: Penn State
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 14-0 | 23-6 | — |
| 2. Harvard | 10-4 | 18-6 | -4 |
| 3. George Mason | 8-6 | 13-17 | -6 |
| T-4. Princeton | 7-7 | 13-10 | -7 |
| T-4. Saint Francis | 7-7 | 12-15 | -7 |
| 6. NJIT | 6-8 | 12-17 | -8 |
| T-7. Rutgers-Newark | 2-12 | 10-15 | -12 |
| T-7. Sacred Heart | 2-12 | 6-22 | -12 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Player of the Year
Joe Sunder, Penn State
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Cody Kessel, Princeton
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Brian Baise, Harvard
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Edgardo Goas, Penn State
Opposite: Cody Kessel, Princeton
Opposite: Mike Kvidahl, George Mason
Outside attacker: Matt Jones, Harvard
Outside attacker: Alex Kane, St. Francis
Outside attacker: Aaron Russell, Penn State
Outside attacker: Joe Sunder, Penn State
Outside attacker: D.J. White, Harvard
Middle attacker: Michael Dye, Princeton
Libero: Connor Curry, Penn State
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Scott Liljestrom, Princeton
Setter: Rob Lothman, Harvard
Setter: Adam Roche, St. Francis
Opposite: Mark Jones, George Mason
Outside attacker: Nick Goodell, Penn State
Outside attacker: T.J. Jurko, NJIT
Middle attacker: Piotr Dabrowski, George Mason
Middle attacker: Nick Turko, Penn State
Middle attacker: Ryan Williams, St. Francis
Libero: Brady Smith, NJIT
2011 season
Champions: Penn State
TAIT DIVISION
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 10-0 | 24-7 | — |
| 2. George Mason | 8-2 | 17-11 | -2 |
| T-3. Springfield | 4-6 | 18-15 | -6 |
| T-3. Rutgers-Newark | 4-6 | 17-12 | -6 |
| 5. Saint Francis | 3-7 | 10-19 | -8 |
| 6. Princeton | 1-9 | 3-19 | -9 |
HAY DIVISION
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Juniata | 8-0 | 18-12 | — |
| T-2. NYU | 5-3 | 13-9 | -3 |
| T-2. Sacred Heart | 5-3 | 13-9 | -3 |
| T-4. Harvard | 1-7 | 9-13 | -7 |
| T-4. NJIT | 1-7 | 7-21 | -7 |
Uvaldo Acosta Memorial EIVA Player of the Year
Joe Sunder, Penn State
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Connor Mortland, NYU
Bob Sweeney EIVA Coach of the Year
Kevin Moore, Juniata
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Edgardo Goas, Penn State
Setter: Brandon Joyner, George Mason
Setter: Jeff Zornig, Rutgers-Newark
Opposite: Alberto Bravo, Springfield
Opposite: Mark Jones, George Mason
Outside attacker: Joe Sunder, Penn State
Middle attacker: Greg Falcone, Springfield
Middle attacker: Cal Palumbo, Springfield
Middle attacker: Nick Turko, Penn State
Libero: Dennis Del Valle, Penn State
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Connor Mortland, NYU
Opposite: Tom Comfort, Penn State
Opposite: Austin Pappas, Rutgers-Newark
Outside attacker: Taylor Faunteroy, NYU
Outside attacker: Enzo Mackenzie, Sacred Heart
Outside attacker: Jace Olsen, Penn State
Outside attacker: Chris Vrooman, Juniata
Middle attacker: Shaun Sibley, George Mason
Middle attacker: Ben Wolff, Juniata
Libero: John Wappler, St. Francis
2010 season
Champions: Penn State
TAIT DIVISION
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Penn State | 10-0 | 24-8 | — |
| 2. Princeton | 5-5 | 15-10 | -5 |
| T-3. George Mason | 4-6 | 8-19 | -6 |
| T-3. Springfield | 4-6 | 20-11 | -6 |
| T-3. Saint Francis | 4-6 | 12-15 | -6 |
| 6. Juniata | 3-7 | 9-13 | -7 |
HAY DIVISION
| Team | EIVA | Overall | MB |
| 1. Rutgers-Newark | 8-0 | 13-13 | — |
| 2. Sacred Heart | 5-3 | 18-11 | -3 |
| 3. Harvard | 3-5 | 5-16 | -5 |
| T-4. NYU | 2-6 | 6-17 | -6 |
| T-4. NJIT | 2-6 | 3-19 | -6 |
EIVA Uvaldo Acosta Memorial Player of the Year
Max Lipsitz, Penn State
EIVA Newcomer of the Year
Pat Schwagler, Princeton
EIVA Bob Sweeney Coach of the Year
Sam Shweisky, Princeton
First-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Edgardo Goas, Penn State
Setter: Eric Shoemaker, Springfield
Opposite: William Price, Penn State
Opposite: Jordan Varee, Saint Francis
Outside attacker: AJ Nally, Springfield
Middle attacker: Jon Keller, Rutgers-Newark
Middle attacker: Max Lipsitz, Penn State
Middle attacker: Jeff McCown, Princeton
Middle attacker: Lance Rogers, George Mason
Libero: Dennis Del Valle, Penn State
Second-Team All-EIVA
Setter: Scott Liljestrom, Princeton
Setter: Jeff Zornig, Rutgers-Newark
Outside attacker: Marcin Midura, Rutgers-Newark
Outside attacker: Nick Rivett, Saint Francis
Outside attacker: Pat Schwagler, Princeton
Outside attacker: Joe Sunder, Penn State
Middle attacker: Greg Falcone, Springfield
Middle attacker: Pete Freyer, Saint Francis
Middle attacker: Cal Palumbo, Springfield